Two construction companies have been fined after a drilling operative sustained fractures to his neck and back when a temporary platform loaded with concrete debris collapsed on top of him.
Steve Zschoch, now 60, was working for contractors Diacutt Limited on 23 February 2024 at Paxton House in the City of London. The refurbishment project, which was being run by principal contractor Roots Contractors Limited, involved cutting openings through five concrete floors to create a service riser shaft.
Roots Contractors Ltd had instructed its carpenters to build temporary wooden platforms under each opening to collect the 16kg concrete cores and debris that were generated by the cutting.
Zschoch had been cutting an opening on the third floor, working directly under one of the temporary platforms, when it suddenly gave way and collapsed on top of him, along with chunks of concrete that had not been cleared away.
He described being “folded up like a concertina.” He sustained injuries including fractures to his neck, his back and a bleed on his brain. He described the profound impact of the incident on his day to day life;
Zschoch said: “The impact this incident has had on me has been life changing in so many ways.
“Not just in mobility issues but in my confidence to do just about anything.
“Even simple domestic tasks, like using the launderette or going to the shops can overwhelm me now. Emotionally as well as physically.”
An HSE investigation found that there was no design for the temporary platforms and no calculation had been made for the safe level of loading.
While an inspection form for the platform was completed, it failed to identify any issues with the design, and the person tasked to complete it was a not a competent temporary works coordinator.
HSE also found deficiencies in the planning, managing and monitoring of the work by the contractor.
Risk assessments and method statements provided by Diacutt in advance were inconsistent and their requirements for the principal contractor to provide ‘crash decks’ were unclear.
There was no supervision of the drilling team by Diacutt management in the week leading up to the incident or on the day.
Roots Contractors Limited of Ewell, Surrey, pleaded guilty to breaching safety regulations and was fined £19,333 plus costs of £5,548 at a hearing at Westminster Magistrates’ court.
Diacutt Limited of Croydon also pleaded guilty and was fined £13,000 plus costs of £5,548 at the same hearing.
HSE inspector Lucy Ellison-Dunn said: “People rightly expect that when they go to work, they are not put in unnecessary danger, and this entirely avoidable incident had the effect of seriously injuring Mr Zschoch and ending his construction career much earlier than he wanted.
“Those providing temporary works have a duty to ensure that any temporary structure is properly designed and constructed to withstand any foreseeable load that might be imposed on it.
“This means having appropriate arrangements in place to manage temporary works. Contractors should ensure all construction work is properly planned, managed and monitored to ensure workers can carry out their work safely.”
Two construction companies have been fined after a drilling operative sustained fractures to his neck and back when a temporary platform loaded with concrete debris collapsed on top of him.
Steve Zschoch, now 60, was working for contractors Diacutt Limited on 23 February 2024 at Paxton House in the City of London. The refurbishment project, which was being run by principal contractor Roots Contractors Limited, involved cutting openings through five concrete floors to create a service riser shaft.
Roots Contractors Ltd had instructed its carpenters to build temporary wooden platforms under each opening to collect the 16kg concrete cores and debris that were generated by the cutting.
Zschoch had been cutting an opening on the third floor, working directly under one of the temporary platforms, when it suddenly gave way and collapsed on top of him, along with chunks of concrete that had not been cleared away.
He described being “folded up like a concertina.” He sustained injuries including fractures to his neck, his back and a bleed on his brain. He described the profound impact of the incident on his day to day life;
Zschoch said: “The impact this incident has had on me has been life changing in so many ways.
“Not just in mobility issues but in my confidence to do just about anything.
“Even simple domestic tasks, like using the launderette or going to the shops can overwhelm me now. Emotionally as well as physically.”
An HSE investigation found that there was no design for the temporary platforms and no calculation had been made for the safe level of loading.
While an inspection form for the platform was completed, it failed to identify any issues with the design, and the person tasked to complete it was a not a competent temporary works coordinator.
HSE also found deficiencies in the planning, managing and monitoring of the work by the contractor.
Risk assessments and method statements provided by Diacutt in advance were inconsistent and their requirements for the principal contractor to provide ‘crash decks’ were unclear.
There was no supervision of the drilling team by Diacutt management in the week leading up to the incident or on the day.
Roots Contractors Limited of Ewell, Surrey, pleaded guilty to breaching safety regulations and was fined £19,333 plus costs of £5,548 at a hearing at Westminster Magistrates’ court.
Diacutt Limited of Croydon also pleaded guilty and was fined £13,000 plus costs of £5,548 at the same hearing.
HSE inspector Lucy Ellison-Dunn said: “People rightly expect that when they go to work, they are not put in unnecessary danger, and this entirely avoidable incident had the effect of seriously injuring Mr Zschoch and ending his construction career much earlier than he wanted.
“Those providing temporary works have a duty to ensure that any temporary structure is properly designed and constructed to withstand any foreseeable load that might be imposed on it.
“This means having appropriate arrangements in place to manage temporary works. Contractors should ensure all construction work is properly planned, managed and monitored to ensure workers can carry out their work safely.”
